Tag: what is a 529 plan

The following is a guest post from Dr. Jeffrey Keimer. Dr. Keimer is a 2011 graduate of Albany College of Pharmacy and Health Sciences and pharmacy manager for a regional drugstore chain in Vermont. He and his wife Alex have been pursuing financial independence since 2016. Check out Jeff’s new book, FIRE Rx: The Pharmacist’s Guide to Financial Independence to learn how to create an actionable plan to reach financial independence.

Let’s face it, paying for college stinks. Whether you are in school, you’re trying to keep up with your child’s tuition which tends to increase by twice the rate of inflation every year, or you’ve graduated and are facing paying back student loans, the cost of higher education can be a tremendous burden.

So what can you do about it?

Well, the first, and most obvious answer here is you need to save for it. Sure, there are other things you can do to reduce the cost of college such as scholarship hacking (i.e., applying for every scholarship under the sun in the hope you get some) or taking a job with a college offering tuition reimbursement as a benefit, but those kinds of silver bullets aren’t the norm. No, chances are you’re going to need to start thinking about college expenses well in advance and start saving sooner rather than later.

Thankfully, the government gives college savers a helping hand in the form of tax-advantaged savings vehicles; the two most popular choices are the Coverdell Education Savings Account and the 529 plan. In this post, we’re going to do a deep dive into the more popular latter option: the 529.

What is a 529 Plan?

In a nutshell, a 529 plan is simply an account that allows money to be invested and grow tax-free for future education expenses. This is similar to other tax-advantaged accounts like an IRA or 401(k). Unlike those plans, money in a 529 plan can only be withdrawn (without penalty) to pay for qualified education expenses. If the expense qualifies, the money coming out of the plan also comes out tax-free. What’s more, contributions made to 529 plans can have some tax benefits too depending on your state (more on this later). In this respect, the 529 falls somewhere in between a Roth IRA and an HSA in terms of preferential tax treatment.

Before opening one, there are several things to consider; and most, if not all, will depend on your situation. What follows is a brief overview of seven main considerations before starting a 529 plan and it is not an all-inclusive list. As always, if you have questions about how best to incorporate these concepts into your financial plan, make sure to reach out to a financial professional like those at YFP Planning.

Let’s dive in.

What to Consider Before Starting a 529 Plan

1. Which Type of 529 Plan is Right for You?

Like many things in life, even those trying to save for college can find themselves facing the tyranny of choice. Case in point, as of when this post was written, there are 150 different plans considered to be 529 plans. But fear not! We’ll help you sort through it.

First off, you need to decide on the general type of 529 plan you want. While the term “529 Plan” is sometimes used as a catch-all for these savings vehicles, there are only two distinct types of plans governed by section 529 of the Internal Revenue Code: prepaid tuition plans and savings plans.

With a prepaid tuition plan, you do just that: pre-pay tuition. The idea here is that since the price of college tuition tends to increase quite a bit over time, it’s better to prepay to lock in tuition prices at today’s rates. In addition, by using a prepaid plan, there can be far less guesswork in the planning process. Sounds good, right? There’s a catch.

As you may have guessed, when you pre-pay tuition, you’re pre-paying at an institution’s (or institutions’) going rate. As such, you may be limiting where the funds in the account can be spent. After all, you can’t pre-pay 4 years’ worth of tuition for an inexpensive state school and then expect Harvard to say you’re all paid up for there as well. What happens with prepaid plans is that the pre-payment is based on the tuition rates at schools either in a particular state or within a private network of schools outlined by the plan; and to use the prepaid plan as intended, the beneficiary would need to attend one of the covered schools. If the beneficiary chooses to go somewhere else (or doesn’t get into a prepaid school) options are generally limited to changing the beneficiary of the account, rolling the account value into a 529 savings plan, or getting a refund (usually with fees applied).

On the other hand, 529 savings plans offer much more flexibility. With a savings plan, you’re able to use account funds for qualifying expenses at thousands of colleges and universities in the US and abroad as well as private/religious K-12 tuition (up to $10,000 annually). In addition, money added to a savings plan can be invested, similar to a workplace retirement plan, allowing you to grow the account faster when compared to a prepaid plan. Finally, unlike prepaid tuition plans, where participation can be restricted depending on the beneficiary’s state of residence, 529 savings plans are generally open to anyone.

However, not all 529 savings plans are created equal and some are, objectively, better than others. Separating the wheat from the chaff here can be a kind of daunting process too as savings plans comprise the vast majority of available 529 plans and there are several variables to consider for each; such as state-specific tax breaks, plan fees, and investment choice. What’s more, unlike a prepaid tuition plan where the amount you need to save is explicit, market returns (which are relatively unpredictable) are going to play a more central role in the plan’s success. Given the added uncertainty, a savings plan might not work for everyone.

Finally, I should note that while many people choose to use one type of plan or the other exclusively, there’s no law saying you can’t use both. For some, combining the greater certainty of the prepaid plan with the flexibility of a savings plan by investing in both can be a good fit.

2. Should You Use an In-State 529?

Once you’ve decided the kind of 529 plan you want to use, it’s time to start narrowing the list of available plans to the one best suited for the plan’s beneficiary, and you! Generally, the next step here is to decide whether or not to use a plan specific to your state of residence.

Unlike other tax-advantaged accounts such as IRAs and HSAs, the federal government doesn’t offer any tax incentives for 529 contributions. However, depending on your state of residence, contributions made to a 529 plan can have state income tax incentives such as deductions or credits. Here’s where things can get a little challenging. The rules surrounding state tax incentives are, much like state pharmacy laws, kind of a patchwork across the country.

For instance, in my home state of Vermont, my wife and I get a 10% tax credit on up to $5,000 worth of 529 contributions per beneficiary per year as long as we make those contributions to the official in-state 529 plan. If we lived in Pennsylvania though, we could get a tax deduction on up to $30,000 worth of contributions per beneficiary per year and it doesn’t matter what 529 plan we use. But on the flip side, if we lived in California, it doesn’t matter how much we contribute or what plan we contribute to because California doesn’t offer any tax incentives for 529 contributions.

As you can see, the relative value of these tax incentives can vary a lot from state to state. You could live in a state that heavily rewards saving for college…or not so much. When choosing a 529 plan, paying attention to how your state treats contributions can help you avoid leaving money on the table allowing you to save for college much more efficiently.

3. Is Your In-State Plan a Good Investment?

A saying in the investment world is “don’t let the tax tail wag the investment dog” and I think it’s extremely relevant when choosing a 529 savings plan. When it comes to investments, 529 savings plans share a lot in common with workplace retirement plans such as 401(k)s. They both limit your choice of investments to a short menu of options and tend to offer the same types of investments no matter where you go. Typically, this means an age-based allocation strategy (similar to a retirement plan’s target-date fund) and some stock, bond, and cash choices for those who want a more custom portfolio.

So if there’s not much difference between savings plans in terms of what they offer, why should an investor care about which plan they choose?

Fees!

Just as I said in an earlier post on investing basics, fees can have an enormous impact on your overall investment returns. Their effect on the performance of a 529 savings plan is no different. While many plans offer solid low-cost investment options, some do not. And worse yet, some plans charge high admin or advisor fees on top of those already charged by the funds you invest in. Yikes!

So going back to the old investing adage “don’t let the tax tail wag the investment dog,” the presence of high fees within your in-state options is a good reason to think twice before investing. After all, getting a couple of hundred dollars back in taxes but losing thousands due to fees over time is the very definition of penny-wise, pound-foolish.

It’s for this reason that many people who choose to use a 529 savings plan opt for an out-of-state plan. Once you’ve decided to invest outside the limited options provided by your state, you’re free to choose whatever plan you want; some of which explicitly market themselves as low-fee options.

In addition, depending on your state, it may be possible to invest in the in-state option, get a tax break, and then later, move the investment to a more fee-friendly out-of-state plan (so-called “deduct and dash”). Yes, it’s possible to have your cake and eat it too. This sort of thing isn’t allowed in all states though, and doing so in the wrong state might cause tax penalties. Be sure to check first with a CPA or another qualified tax professional before pursuing such a plan.

4. What Types of Expenses are Covered?

When I was in college, I spent a whole lot of money on a variety of things that were loosely affiliated with my status as a full-time student. However, a number of those expenses that I would’ve considered to be “college-related” wouldn’t have been considered qualified higher education expenses covered by a 529 savings plan. Here’s a short list of what would’ve made the cut:

• Tuition and fees
• Room and board (limited to the costs published by the college attended)
• Textbooks
• Computers (related to schooling only, sorry no gaming or crypto mining rigs)
• Student loan repayment ($10k lifetime max per beneficiary as of 2021)
• Tuition for private or religious K-12 education (up to $10k per year)

But what about other things such as transportation or the cost of an internet connection for the apartment? Surely those are “education-related expenses” and would be covered, right? Wrong! This is where people trying to pay for everything related to a child’s schooling can get into trouble when using 529 funds.

So what happens if money from a 529 savings plan gets tapped for a non-qualified expense? First off, relax, no one from the government is going to come and break down your door about it. However, you will owe ordinary income tax on the portion of the withdrawal that comes from account earnings as well as a 10% penalty; very similar to what would happen if you withdrew from a Roth IRA before age 59 ½.

5. What are Your Plan’s Contribution Limits?

So just how much money can you squirrel away in a 529 savings plan? Well, the most accurate answer here is “it depends.” Contribution limits are set not by the federal government, but instead by the states, and it ends up being another legal patchwork across the country. In addition, contribution limits are not based on some yearly amount that you can put in, but by a limit on the balance of the account. Once the account’s value reaches the prescribed limit, no more contributions can be made until the balance falls back below it.

On the other hand, even states boasting the lowest allowable balances let you build up quite the war chest before the limits are reached. For example, as of 2021, even the strictest of state-sponsored plans have a limit of $235,000 per beneficiary; quite a bit if you ask me. And if that weren’t enough, some states will even let you have over half a million in a 529. At that point, if you can’t pay for college, you’re doing it wrong.

6. Is “Front Loading” Contributions the Right Move?

Another question often asked about 529 plans is whether you should front-load the contributions (aka. lump sum invest) or spread them out over time (aka dollar cost average). Fortunately, there’s some guidance on this and generally speaking, it’s better to invest as much as you can as early as possible. As the adage goes “time in the market beats timing the market.” The more time your investments have to grow, the better chance you have for those investments to grow.

In addition, the IRS makes a special exception for 529 contributions when it comes to gift taxes. Normally when you give money to a child, there’s a $15,000 per year cap per person, per child ($30,000 for couples filing jointly). However, the IRS makes an exception for gifts going to 529 accounts, allowing you to front-load 5 years of contributions into one. This could mean up to $150,000 going into a 529 account in a single year! Now I know what you’re thinking, that sounds pretty baller even on a pharmacist’s salary, but hear me out. Given the exception, front-loading a 529 account like this can be a very good play for those receiving an inheritance or other significant windfall. While it won’t keep you from paying taxes on the money you get, it can keep that money growing tax-free and for a good cause.

7. What if My Kid Doesn’t Use It?

Finally, when thinking about using a 529 as part of the financial plan, you should consider what to do with it if the original beneficiary doesn’t use all the money in it to fund their education. Or who knows, maybe they don’t use any of it! What happens then?

Fortunately, the 529 isn’t a use-it-or-lose-it type of savings vehicle like the flexible spending account (FSA) you may have at work for healthcare expenses. The money saved in one will continue to be there regardless of what your kid chooses to do in life. So if they don’t use it all does it make sense to just cash it out? Maybe, but transferring the account to someone else will probably make more sense when you consider the taxes and penalties you’d have to pay on such a move.

So how does that work? Well, it could be as simple as just changing the name of the beneficiary on the account. First kid not going to use the money? Now that money belongs to the second kid. Done. You could even name yourself as the new beneficiary to help fund yourself going back to school, something that may become necessary in the future. As Yuval Noah Harari points out in his book, 21 Lessons for the 21st Century, the speed at which new technologies are disrupting old industries these days may make it difficult for anyone to stay in the same profession for 40 years; especially those in highly specialized ones such as pharmacy. Given that, utilizing a 529 account to fund not just your childrens’ but further your education by taking advantage of their ease of transferability can help protect you and your family from this kind of uncertainty.

But what if the person you want to name as a beneficiary already has their own 529 account? No worries, you can just combine the accounts once a year through a rollover. A rollover can also be a good choice if you move states and the new state you’re in has a better plan.

Conclusion

Overall, 529 plans can be a solid choice as a savings vehicle for future education expenses. With their preferential tax treatment, high contribution limits, and ease of transferability, choosing to use a 529 plan versus alternatives such as a taxable brokerage account can make a lot of sense.

529 Plans aren’t without their drawbacks though. The quality and tax benefits of 529 plans can vary from state to state, with some states making investments in their 529 almost a no-brainer and others…well, not so much. In addition, the requirement to spend 529 money on “qualified higher education expenses” only without incurring a significant penalty, can definitely be a turn-off for those who don’t care for restrictions on their savings.

Need help determining how to best save for your child’s education?

In the end, the suitability of a 529 plan as a savings vehicle is going to come down to your family’s financial plan. The seven considerations I’ve spoken to above are good for getting an appreciation of these types of plans and how they might fit into your plan. But it’s no substitute for doing in-depth research or working with a financial professional. If you think you need more help deciding whether a 529 plan is a good fit or which one to choose, feel free to reach out to the team of fee-only, comprehensive CERTIFIED FINANCIAL PLANNERS TM at YFP Planning. They can walk you through all the ins and outs of saving for college and getting the most from your customized financial plan.

You can book a free discovery meeting with our team to see if YFP Planning is the right fit for you.

Current Student Loan Refinance Offers

Advertising Disclosure