Should You Refinance Your Mortgage?
Nate Hedrick, the Real Estate RPh, joins Tim Ulbrich to talk about all things mortgage refinancing. They talk about what it is, how to qualify, the costs associated with refinancing a mortgage, how to determine the break even point and how Nate recently evaluated his own mortgage refinance.
About Today’s Guest
Nate Hedrick is a 2013 graduate of Ohio Northern University. By day, he is a clinical pharmacist and program advisor for Medical Mutual. By night and weekend, he works with pharmacists to buy, sell, flip, or rent homes as a licensed real estate agent with Berkshire Hathaway in Cleveland, Ohio. He has helped dozens of pharmacists achieve their goal of owning a house and is the founder of www.RealEstateRPH.com, a real estate blog that covers everything from first-time home buying to real estate investing.
Summary
Nate Hedrick, the Real Estate RPh, is back on the podcast to discuss mortgage refinancing. Nate explains that a mortgage is a bank or lender giving you money to pay for a home and you, the borrower, have a certain amount of time (term) to pay that money back. In mortgage refinancing a lender or bank gives the leftover amount to pay the existing mortgage off and you get a brand new one which essentially resets your loan. It’s possible to refinance your mortgage with the same lender. People chose to refinance their mortgage to reduce their monthly payment, reduce overall interest, get better equity in their home if the house went up in value, eliminate PMI or to reduce the term of the loan.
You likely qualify for a mortgage refinance if you already have a mortgage. To get a good refinance offer, three categories will be looked at: the equity in your home, credit score, and other debt load.
Since this is a new mortgage, you’ll incur the same costs as you did when you purchased your home (closing costs, title fees, etc). Nate cautions that advertisements for no closing costs may not be completely truthful as those costs might be rolled into the loan which you’ll end up paying interest on.
To figure out if mortgage refinancing makes sense for your situation, you have to know your current interest rate and monthly payment, what that rate and payment will change to, what your overall payment is going to be and how long you are going to live in that house. The length you’ll be in your house is really important to consider when looking at refinancing depending on the amount of closing costs you’ll have to pay with your new mortgage.
Nate and Tim suggest exploring several lenders and banks if you’re considering refinancing your mortgage. YFP recently partnered with Credible for mortgage refinancing. You can compare up to 6 lenders at a time and receive quotes in under 5 minutes. Click here to compare multiple lenders with Credible.
Mentioned on the Show
- Compare Mortgage Refinance Lenders with Credible
- Real Estate RPh
- YFP Facebook Group
- YFP 064: 6 Steps to Home Buying (Part 1) w/ Nate Hedrick
- YFP 065: 6 Steps to Home Buying (Part 2) w/ Nate Hedrick
- Refinance Your Mortgage – Compare Multiple Lenders with Credible
- Life and Disability Insurance for Pharmacists
- YFP Planning
- YFP Real Estate Concierge Service
Episode Transcript
Tim Ulbrich: Hey, what’s up, everybody? Welcome to this week’s episode of the Your Financial Pharmacist podcast. Excited to be here and to welcome back Nate Hedrick, the Real Estate RPH, as we talk about mortgage refinancing, including Nate’s own experiences, and we’ll talk about a question we’ve had from a listener, a community member, as well. So Nate, welcome back to the show.
Nate Hedrick: Thanks, Tim. Nice to be here.
Tim Ulbrich: So I was doing some accounting this morning. I think you officially now may have the record for the number of times you’ve appeared on the podcast. So we’re excited to have you back.
Nate Hedrick: Yeah, I expect my championship belt to be sent in the mail as well. I’ll give you my address after this.
Tim Ulbrich: Awesome. So we’ve talked before. We know how things can get expensive. We’ve done episodes before on home buying, we know of course there’s lots to consider. We did a previous episode on all costs involved in home buying, evaluating the rent versus the buy. It’s not just the mortgage payment, of course it’s the taxes, the insurance, the HOA fees, utilities, etc. And you know, for our listeners, when it comes to the mortgage and how much of a factor that can play in your overall financial plan, it typically is a big chunk of their monthly budget. And unless you move or downsize, many of these costs that come along with home buying are things that you can’t change. However, one thing that you might be able to change is the interest rate. And that can be accomplished through a refinance, which we’re going to talk about here today. So Nate, here we are, 2020, and I think we take for granted rates today in 2020. But rates have not always been where they are today. So just give us a quick history lesson on kind of mortgage interest rates and probably for many of us, what our parents were dealing with back in the early ‘80s.
Nate Hedrick: Yeah, it’s funny. This is something that I actually learned in real estate classes and for some reason, never knew up until that point. But for years, even if you look 30 years ago, early ‘80s, end of the ‘70s, interest rates were like credit cards for houses. I mean, you’re talking 15%, 16%, 17%, 18% for a mortgage, which just — it feels absolutely crazy in today’s world. I mean, we’re at 3.5%, roughly 4% on prime, so that is such a huge difference for us. And it’s something that I don’t think a lot of people even realize if you’re in our generation.
Tim Ulbrich: Yeah, I think so too. And so here we are, as you mentioned, rates, depending on the term, depending on a whole host of factors, which we’ll talk about here today, much, much, much lower, whether that’s 3.5%, 4%, 4.5%, it’s still notably lower than interest rates that were in the teens. And I always give my parents a hard time, ‘Yes, you dealt with that. But also, let’s look at the prices of homes back at that time period.’ So basic definition, mortgage refinancing, what is it in terms of basic things our listeners should know before we talk about the reasons and the hows and all the qualifying factors.
Nate Hedrick: Yeah, absolutely. So a mortgage in itself is just basically the bank giving you money or a lender giving you money to pay for a house. And you have some term to pay that back, whether it’s a 15-year, a 30-year or something in between, you’ve got a period of time which to pay that back. Well, the mortgage refinance is effectively a resetting of that loan. You’ve either got the same lender or a different lender who is giving you the money to cover the leftover amount you have on your current mortgage, and you get a brand new one. And that can be the exact same term, that can be an extended term, a shortened term. There’s all different ways to do it. And we can talk about those details, but effectively, it’s a reset of that loan.
Tim Ulbrich: Awesome. And I think for many folks listening, especially with the rates where they are at today, most notably, we think of a refinance to reduce your monthly payment, reduce the overall interest that you pay over the course of the loan, but what else is out there? Why might somebody refinance beyond those two factors?
Nate Hedrick: Yeah, the ones that I see a lot too are your house has gone up in value, so you actually want to get a better equity on that property so you can actually get more cash back out of your property itself. You can use it to eliminate PMI, that’s actually why my wife and I did it. And we can talk through that, but we actually wanted to get rid of PMI, and it was the easiest way for us to do that. You can actually just reduce the loan term. Maybe if you’re really driving toward that FIRE movement like we’ve been talking about and you want to get that paid down that much faster, you can reduce the actual loan term to a reduced interest rate and a number of other things to basically get that paid off that much faster.
Tim Ulbrich: So if we have somebody listening, you know, I’m going to give them my situation for Jess and I. We moved here to Columbus fall 2018. You know, interest rates really were at — I say ‘peak,’ but again, if we consider this historically, peak is a relative term. But at the time, we got a 30-year mortgage for 6.25% was our interest rate, wasn’t too long ago. And here we are again with rates lower than that. So I’m guessing many of our listeners are thinking, OK, maybe I’ve got a rate where this makes sense. And we’ll talk about how you evaluate whether or not that makes sense and where the break-even is. But how does one qualify? And what are the steps that are involved that if somebody’s thinking or finding themselves in a similar situation, to determine if this is for me, how do I begin that qualification process?
Nate Hedrick: Yeah, so if you currently have a mortgage, you pretty much automatically qualify for a refinance. The tricks to how you get a good refinance come down to a number of factors. So one is the equity in your home. That’s probably the most important factor, quite honestly. Most lenders are going to ask you that up front. So what is your current loan, basically? So if you took out a 90% loan, basically you put 10% down on your house a year ago, you probably haven’t built up a lot of equity in that home, right? You’ve been paying it off for a year, but most of those payments are going toward interest, not toward principal. And the actual equity you have, the ability to refinance probably hasn’t changed very much. There’s not been enough time for it to go up in value. And similarly, you haven’t been able to pay down the debt that you have. So that really is the key factor. How much equity do you have in the home right now? And how has that changed from your original loan? That’s kind of step one. The next thing is going to be based on like your credit score. So if you’ve got a better credit score, you’re going to qualify for better rates. So if you’ve bought the house five years ago, let’s say, and your credit score has gone up 100 points since then, you may qualify for very different rates than you did just that five years ago. So that’s a question to kind of ask yourself. And then beyond that too, it’s just what other factors are going into it? Do you have other debtload that the lender should be concerned about? It’s basically all the questions they ask you on an original mortgage and making sure that you’re a qualified candidate for that original mortgage again.
Tim Ulbrich: And I think that’s where for so many of our listeners, you know, we think of the life stage that often pharmacists, especially new practitioners, are in in terms of so many variables changing where, you know, income may have gone up, credit scores may have gone better, other debt has come down, perhaps they’ve paid down some of their mortgage. And obviously, that would make them more favorable, depending on the personal situation. The one thing, Nate, I’ve seen a little bit — and I don’t know if you’ve run into this — is especially recently as some markets have gotten really hot, if people got into bidding wars on a home where they, you know, were making just crazy offers, well above whatever was kind of market value at the time, and depending on what’s happened in those markets since then and how long it’s been, the appraisal process is going to be very important here to determine what that equity position is, correct?
Nate Hedrick: Absolutely. Yeah, the appraisal’s really what it all comes down to, and that’s effectively the bank sending someone to your home or sometimes they do a desktop appraisal where they’re researching it online only and not actually driving out. But they’re determining what is the market value of your home? There’s no one else bidding on it, right? You’re not actually up for sale. So they have to kind of use other area comps to determine what is the effective value of your home? And we’re going to base our loan on that amount.
Tim Ulbrich: My favorite appraisal story recently, I think I shared this with you, as Jess and I are looking at the refi process — we’re actually in the middle of this right now — is about six months ago, we got a HELOC on the home as we were looking at doing some real estate investing, and we haven’t done anything with it. But at that time, as a part of that, we got an appraisal done. And that came in at $10,000 less than we actually purchased the home. And now as we’re going through the mortgage refinance, you know, it was at our local credit union that I work with. And obviously as lending has become a little bit looser here again in 2020, couple quick pushes of the button on the computer and that appraisal is $40,000 different than the one on the HELOC. Same institution.
Nate Hedrick: Sounds about right.
Tim Ulbrich: And that came out $30,000 higher than we purchased the home. So I think that just speaks to some of the variability you see in the appraisal process.
Nate Hedrick: Yeah, a lot of that speaks to too basically how the banks make their money and how they want to get those loans, right? It’s better to have you in there for a long time. A HELOC is kind of boring to them, so they’re not going to appraise it very competitively.
Tim Ulbrich: But we like to think it’s objective, right? So.
Nate Hedrick: Exactly.
Tim Ulbrich: So let’s talk about costs. I think this is certainly top of mind for folks. You know, of course we can look at it and say, hopefully we get a lower monthly payment, hopefully we’ll reduce the amount we pay over the life of the loan, lots of commercials out there advertising no closing costs. And if somebody goes out and starts to shop, you see a wide range of what’s advertised as $0 closing costs to, as we’ll share an example here from a listener, question what can be fairly significant closing costs. So what are the reason for the differences? And what are some of the costs that are involved in a refinance process?
Nate Hedrick: Yeah, so like I said at the beginning, this is effectively a new mortgage. You’re resetting the button on your actual debt. So the banks and the lenders are going to treat it just the same way. So there’s the same level of closing costs, the same level of effort. They’ve got appraisals, they have to pay for title fees and all sorts of things that need to be taken care of. And while it feels like it should be less because you already live in the house and you already have the title and all that stuff, a lot of those things still persist. So just like when you get a regular mortgage, you will actually get basically a good faith estimate that will lay out all of those costs and what it’s going to be. Now, you talked about no closing costs. And there are some situations where there are truly no closing costs. But a lot of times what that means is that no direct out-of-pocket closing costs. They’re going to roll them into the loan. So if you have $5,000 in closing costs and your current mortgage is $180,000, well, your new mortgage would be at $185,000. And the idea is you just roll that into the loan, you’ll figure it out with interest later. So those closing costs advertisements can be a little bit misleading at times.
Tim Ulbrich: Yeah. And I think that’s such an important point. I’m glad you brought that up is really making sure you’re digging into that good faith estimate and doing your homework to understand what exactly are the individual line item charges, especially — as we’ll talk about in a moment — if you’re comparing multiple offers, getting as close to an apples-to-apples comparison as you can and really understanding what are you paying for now versus what’s being rolled into the mortgage, which ultimately you’re going to pay back with interest, you know, along the way, which may not be a bad thing. It’s just you have to be aware of what you’re working on and weighing how much you want to pay out of pocket versus how much you want to roll into the loan. So to your point, you’re resetting the mortgage, so think of it as somebody who’s buying a home for the first time, all those closing costs, again, you’re going to be evaluating and hopefully something you’re preparing. So I’m somebody listening, Nate, and I’m looking at a situation where OK, maybe I’ve got a 30-year mortgage at 4.5%, I’ve paid off two years, let’s say, 28 years left of a 30-year term, I hear that rates are lower, I’m listening to this podcast, how do I determine whether or not this makes sense? Talk me through how do you think through this process?
Nate Hedrick: Absolutely. So just like when we go to buy a house, right, I recommend all my clients shop around for a couple different mortgages. Right now, lenders are chomping at the bit to get you to refinance with them, even if it’s — this is ridiculous — but even if it’s the current lender you have, they can’t wait to refinance your loan, right? They just want you to secure your business as long as they can. So you give a call to a local branch or a lender that you know or a lender that your listing agent has recommended, anything like that, and they’ll immediately be like, ‘Oh yeah, refinance, let me get you to our refinance department. Here’s our refinancing guy,’ or what have you. And so they’ll be able to tell you quite quickly, you know, based on a 10-question survey that they’ll have over the phone with you, ‘Here’s what we expect your rate to be, here’s what some of the breakdown of what you’d actually pay in closing costs,’ I mean, I called up when we did our refinance, I called up three different lenders and within, I mean, within an hour, all three of those lenders had gotten me a reasonable result of what I was going to be able to refinance with.
Tim Ulbrich: Absolutely. Yeah, and I did the same thing. So you know, I actually reached out to the institution that currently holds our mortgage, and to your point, I think I get something in the mail every three days from them. I haven’t got any phone calls, but I get lots of mail from the current lender. So I reached out to them, I used the Credible tool that we have on the site, which I’ll talk about at the end, and then I went through our local credit union that I’ve done other business with. And I wanted to just see both experience-wise as well as rate-wise and again, trying to compare some of those costs what’s involved as well. And three very, very different experiences. And I think it speaks to the value of making sure you shop around, just like we talk about with many other things on this show, life insurance, disability, professional liability, etc. So breakeven, how do I figure out does the math make sense on this? So instead of just looking at here’s my current rate, here’s my new rate, here’s my current monthly payment, here’s the future monthly payment under refinance. That’s a good start but one shouldn’t stop there, right? So how do I determine whether or not this makes sense and ultimately get to a breakeven point?
Nate Hedrick: Yeah, so the trick is to know your numbers up front. You have to know what your current interest rate is and what you’re actually paying monthly. And then once you start getting these quotes and start talking to these lenders, you’ll have new data to basically plug into that chart and be able to say, OK, if we’re at 4.5% now and we’re at 3.5% later, what is our monthly payment going to go down to? Or perhaps if I am changing my loan term, what is my monthly payment going to go up to or change to or whatever the case is going to be? But what does that look like? What’s that difference? And is my overall payment going to be lower, my overall interest payment over the life of that loan going to be better? Now, most people, not everybody, but most people don’t live the entire 30 years in one house, right? Most people move on. So the other question is how long am I going to live here? Because if you’re saving $1,000 a year, but the closing costs are $8,000, you better be there at least eight more years for it to make actual sense. So that’s a really important question. I think no matter what you’re doing, the breakeven analysis is how long am I going to be here to basically make up that difference in terms of the costs up front versus the costs saved over the course of years?
Tim Ulbrich: So I think that’s a great way of thinking about how long am I going to be here? And I’m looking at the math, right? So if you’re going to save let’s say $200 a month, taking that figure and then looking at the closing costs, let’s say your closing costs are $3,000, your $200 a month, how long does that $200 a month have to be saved ‘til you get to that breakeven of $3,000? But also looking at, as you mentioned, the total amount of interest, the total payout over the life of the loan. One of the most common things, Nate, that I think I see and I’m sure you see often talking with individuals is somebody who maybe started with a 30-year, they now are let’s say 26 years left, and they go to refinance and they reup a 30-year, so they restart the clock, but they only focus on the monthly payment, right? And they don’t consider the fact that they’re then going to extend the loan another four years, which is the progress that they’ve already made. Correct?
Nate Hedrick: I see people doing this with student loans too.
Tim Ulbrich: That’s right
Nate Hedrick: And you guys have more experience than I do, right? They say, ‘Oh, look at my payment’s lower, this is fantastic. Yeah, my interest rate is lower too. I’m sure it’s great.’ They’ve gone from having three years left to now jumping back to 10 years of loan payments. The overall interest paid over that life is tens of thousands of dollars more, potentially. So you have to factor all three of those things in.
Tim Ulbrich: So I think this is where I would encourage our audience to nerd out, create a spreadsheet, right? So you know what I did, as I mentioned, three different institutions, so I worked with my current lender, worked with Credible, which is then shopping around multiple options, which I’ll reference here in more detail in a moment, and then the credit union. But within each one of those, you’re then going to get different options in terms of 30-year, 20-year, 15-year term. And then even within those, you’re going to have different options that range in terms of whether or not you purchase points. So I think I ended up with the spreadsheet of, I don’t know, 20 or 30 different fields, trying to figure out not only what would that be in terms of monthly payment but then also looking at over the totality to try to determine, OK, if I were to continue on this path as is today, how much would be out-of-pocket? And then how would that work out with each one of these? What about the other side of this, Nate? So somebody who let’s say has a 30-year term right now, maybe they’ve got 26 years left to pay and they’re thinking, maybe I’m going to go down to a 15- or a 20-year, how do you think about this from an opportunity cost standpoint? Because on one hand, somebody might say, ‘Well, this is great. I’m going to save x dollars in interest,’ which they could calculate. On the other hand, they might say, ‘You know, do I really want to be making extra payments when rates are so low? Even if I can save interest, could I be using that money elsewhere?’ Talk us through your thought process there.
Nate Hedrick: Yeah. It’s a great question. It all comes down to kind of what your financial goal is, right? Do you want to be throwing extra money at your mortgage right now? Or are you saving that for something else? Maybe it’s more investing or investing in properties or whatever the case may be. So yeah, it’s a good question. It’s going to be different for everybody, but when we looked at it, actually, we had a 30-year rate when we did our refinance. And we took it down to a 15-year because the amount we saved in interest made our payment not that much different. So for us, it was like, well, we’ll just take 10 years off this mortgage to keep paying effectively what we’re paying now. But we’ll know that we’re saving money in the long-term of the interest paid. It was a feel-good thing for us. And sometimes that’s a better driver than crunching all the numbers.
Tim Ulbrich: You know, this reminds me too, Jess and I were recently talking about this as we were looking at, hey, maybe we go down to a 20- or 15-year, and then of course you have the conversation of OK, what pressure is this higher monthly payment going to put on our financial plan? How much margin do we have? You know, do you have a good emergency fund? All the things we talk about on the show. But might there be any life variables that will change that could either increase or decrease that pressure on your margin, right? So you know, I’m thinking of things like potential job loss or could go the other way, a promotion or addition in terms of children to the family or maybe you have children that are moving out of the household and you have more margin. So it can go either way. And I think the conversation that is so common, just like it is with student loans, is it’s easy to say, ‘Well, let’s just opt for the 30-year, the longer term, and then we’ll make extra payments.’ And not suggesting that’s a bad move whatsoever, obviously it depends on your personal situation. I would just challenge, you know, what’s the reality of that happening when push comes to shove? And I think for some, there’s value in kind of forcing that hand with the more aggressive payment whereas for others, that’s not the move to make. So you’ve got to really take a step back and say, behaviorally, what do we need for our plan? How much margin do we have or not have? Would this put us in a tight position? Do we need that type of behavioral solution? Or can we really depend on ourselves to make that extra payment each and every month, perhaps automate that, but have the buffer if you need it for whatever reason?
Nate Hedrick: Yeah, I think that’s huge. And to make it even more complicated, I know when I was looking at rates, the difference in interest between the 15- and 30-year rate were significant.
Tim Ulbrich: Absolutely.
Nate Hedrick: So they’re enticing you even further to go to that 15-year, and it’s like, ah, now I have to do even more math and figure out what I want to do.
Tim Ulbrich: Absolutely. What about points? You know, this is something that caught my attention — and we’ll talk about an example here from a listener that I think can make this process a little bit more confusing. And I know from personal experience, when my wife and I, Jess, purchased our first home back in 2009, I felt like this as I looked back through paperwork, either I didn’t have the memory of the conversation or it was so subtle that all of a sudden, you know, points were applied and I didn’t really have a full understanding of the process. And I think that’s all too common. So talk to us about what are points? Why might somebody consider them? And just make sure that our listeners feel educated and ready to have that conversation with the lender.
Nate Hedrick: Yeah, it’s funny, I’m seeing this conversation come up less and less. I feel like with interest rates where they are right now, points are not as big as they were a couple of years ago. I’m sure they’re still talked about plenty, but I just don’t see it with my clients as much. But what points basically are is a way to buy down your interest rate. So you pay some amount of money, the bank sets what those point values basically are, and you buy down your interest rate. So if it was 5% and you pay a certain amount that the bank sets to basically get that down to 4.75%, you can pay an upfront cost to reduce the interest of the life of that loan. So you know, the basic principle is that you’re giving away up front cash to pay less over the life of that loan. So in the case where you’re like, this is my forever home, we plan on being here 20 years, it may be very advantageous to give up a little bit more cash up front, knowing that you’re going to have a lower interest payment down the road. Now again, with interest payments this low as they are or interest amounts as low as they are today, I don’t see points as being quite as important. But it is a way to kind of if you really want to get that interest rate down as low as you possibly can and you’ve got some extra cash to throw at the problem, that’s not a bad way to do it.
Tim Ulbrich: And does this just come down again to running your numbers and doing a breakeven analysis, again, thinking of factors like time that you’ll be in the home and how much can you let go of that cash now, what other impact does that have on other financial goals, right? I mean, all of these variables come to play?
Nate Hedrick: Yeah, and it’s funny, this one more than any of them really matters on how long you’re going to be in the home. The bank is always going to make the points advantageous at some number — like it will be like, at 12 years, it will break even. So you’ll know. That point is very obvious. So it all comes down to how long am I going to be here for whether or not the points are worth it.
Tim Ulbrich: So let me — that’s a good segway into a question we had from somebody in the YFP Facebook group. And I think this will help us summarize a lot of what we talked about and just hear and give our listeners kind of an inside Nate’s brain look of how you think about this situation.
Nate Hedrick: Dangerous.
Tim Ulbrich: So this question to the group is, “Would you refinance your mortgage” — it comes from Alena — “Would you refinance your mortgage if current mortgage is 4.6% and new one will be 3.3%?” She goes on to say, “It will lower monthly bill by approximately $200,” so lower monthly payment about $200, “and saves $86,000 for the life of the loan.” And that would be over a 30-year fixed period. “But it will cost $10,000 in closing costs. Just want to hear your thoughts.” So Nate, how would you — obviously, we don’t know every variable here. So big asterisk in how we respond and really just meant for us to kind of talk through from an education standpoint, how would you think through this specific scenario?
Nate Hedrick: Yeah, so this is kind of the classic setup, right? The hook is you’re paying 4.6% right now, wouldn’t you rather be paying 3.3%? Everyone listening to this would say, ‘Yes, that sounds fantastic. I want to take a point and some off of my current interest.’ And then again, you take that a step further and you say, ‘How much does this reduce my monthly payment? Wow, it’s $200 a month. That’s great. What could I do with that extra $200?’ And then again, we’re like, ‘Well it’s a 30-year rate, but who cares? Look, we’re saving $86,000 over the life of the loan. Everything seems to make sense.’ Then that $10,000 number kind of jumps in at the end, and that’s when you have to have that, OK, well how long are we going to be here? Right? If I’m saving $200 a month, at what point am I going to be able to say, ‘Well, that $10,000 was now worth it?’ And how confident am I in that decision to say, I’m going to be here for 15 more years or whatever the case may be.
Tim Ulbrich: Absolutely.
Nate Hedrick: That’s when that — it’s no longer a numbers game. It comes down to what is your life looking like? And how long are you committed to that particular home? So that’s, again, this is actually exactly what I ran into when I was doing my refinance, looking oh, great, these numbers looks fantastic. Everything marches out, makes sense. But wait, how much is closing costs? Oh, I don’t know if we’re going to be here nine more years. That doesn’t make a lot of sense for me.
Tim Ulbrich: Yeah. And here is a great other reminder, get out the spreadsheet, start crunching the numbers, and don’t stop at the monthly payment. You know, what we don’t know here is where they’re at in the current term. So now she’s doing a comparison over the life of the loan. So $86,000 saved over the life of the loan, $10,000 in closing costs, so we’ve got to already subtract $10,000 to say what’s the net difference? $76,000. $200 a month savings, so we know that would be $2,400 a year.
Nate Hedrick: Right.
Tim Ulbrich: So we’re looking at roughly four years to get the breakeven. But the question is how confident are you? And the second question I would add is what else is going on? So how much is that $10,000 needed or treasured? So is this somebody that doesn’t have an emergency fund, you know, is paying off lots of student loan debt, is this somebody that has other goals, wants to strategically invest, to do some other things? Maybe isn’t taking advantage of an employer match retirement account that this could help get kind of that match component if they contribute? So lots of variables here that I think would really get to, again, as we talk about over and over again on the show, not looking at one part of your financial plan in a silo but really taking a step back and saying, what else is going on? Now, if this is somebody who has no debt, every other part of their plan is humming, full emergency fund, they’ve got retirement accounts that are being maxed out, they think they’re going to be in their home forever and they’ve just got cash laying around, which sounds like a pretty sweet position to be in, right, they might look at this differently, right, than somebody else who is a little bit more pressed.
Nate Hedrick: And watch too — it’s funny. This is another great example of when the bank will come and say, ‘Well, it’s $10,000 in closing. But don’t worry, we’ll roll that into the loan.’ So now all of a sudden, your math, it doesn’t actually track as well as it did. You’re paying interest on that $10,000. So watch that. Watch where they’re going to set you upfront with here’s $10,000 in closing costs, and then they’ll roll it into the loan at the back end.
Tim Ulbrich: So one of the things I want to mention as we wrap up here is we are excited about a partnership we’ve rolled recently with Credible. And this really mirrors what we’re doing with some of the other things on life and disability of trying to bring our audience as many options as they possibly can to be able to shop around. And so Credible allows you to, on our platform, check six lenders. You can check the rate with them, and they do a soft credit pull, so it will not have a negative impact on your credit. Very quick, I went through this myself, less than five minutes, very user-friendly platform. And I will say, as somebody who did not have such a great experience with a platform like LendingTree, where I was getting harassed with phone calls for I think really, a couple months, to be honest, I thought this here, they did a nice job here of allowing you to see rates, shop things around, but I wasn’t getting hounded with phone calls. And you only have to upload documents once. So again, as we always say, just as I did, I wouldn’t stop here. I think this is a great place to start. But go to your current lender if you’re refinancing, you know, go to a different lender if there’s a unique product that’s in your area. And again, compare multiple options. And I think Credible is a great resource to get started doing that. And you can learn more and do that by going to YourFinancialPharmacist.com/reduceyourpayment. Again, YourFinancialPharmacist.com/reduceyourpayment. So Nate, talk us through, you just did this. Right?
Nate Hedrick: I closed on it less than a month ago.
Tim Ulbrich: Yeah, and yours was somewhat unique. So I think it would be interesting for our listeners to hear that experience, your thought process, and how you arrived — even if that one may not apply to many people that are listening, I think it’s just a good reminder of thinking of all options that are out there and for them to hear how you and Kristin thought through that process.
Nate Hedrick: Absolutely. So we bought our house five years ago now. It was five years ago in September. And when that five-year mark kind of hit, that’s when I said, ‘We should probably look at refinancing. Rates are really low, we’ve been here for a couple years. Hopefully there’s some good equity built.’ So we started pursuing it, and one of the main drivers was the fact that we’d been paying PMI. So again, fast forward — or rewind before. I was a listing agent before I knew what I was doing in terms of buying a house. We bought early, we put 10% down, we said, this is going to be great. And then we were paying $100 a month in PMI.
Tim Ulbrich: Been there, done that.
Nate Hedrick: Yeah, exactly. Many, many listeners I’m sure are in the same boat. And we actually went to our lender first, and we said, ‘Hey, can you get rid of our PMI? We’ve been paying this much, we think our equity is this. I did my own listing agent appraisal, which is worth nothing, but here’s what I think the house is worth.’ So we applied and they said, ‘No, absolutely not. You have to have x, y, and z loan-to-value.’ They basically said no. So I said, ‘Fine, then I’m going to refinance out of it.’ And I started getting quotes. I went to our current lender, I went to kind of a big bank. I went to one of the lenders that I use for my investing properties, which is kind of a little bit smaller and they’re a little bit more crafty with what they can do. And I just started comparing quotes and kind of getting an idea of what the landscape looked like. And my first thing that I got hit with was, ‘Here’s all your closing costs. This is how much it’s going to cost you.’ And then Kristin and I had to have that discussion, OK, well, how long do we think we’re going to be here? And we’re really kind of in a tossup right now. I think, you know, sometimes we say three more years. Sometimes we say 10 more years. And it’s really hard for us to put a number on that. And so that made the conversation that much more difficult. So anyway, I went back to that small kind of hometown lender that we use for our investment properties and started having conversations about, what other options are there? Is there anything we need to get creative? And actually, she presented me with a pretty unique option that it’s effectively a mortgage, but it’s more of a home equity loan. So you have to have you’re already in the house. It’s only for refinances, and it’s a Home Equity Line of — it’s actually a home equity loan, a home equity term loan is what the official term is. And with this particular product, they had a deal going on where it was a new branch, they wanted to drive business and create value like every other bank, and they offered it with $0 appraisal fee, $0 closing costs, not just rolled in closing costs, but $0 closing costs. And a fixed rate interest, which is huge. No prepayment penalties. I mean, all the things that I was like, ‘Well, this is going to be the catch. And this is what’s going to stop this from working.’ But all of those things I worked through, and there was really no catch. So I had a couple more conversations. I actually called up Tim Baker, our financial planner, made sure it made sense with him too because I hadn’t seen this product before. And everybody said, ‘Yeah, this looks great. I think you’re good.’ And yeah, it’s been a really great way for us to refinance. We got our interest rate cut by a full percentage point, and we didn’t pay $1 in closing costs. The appraisal was free, all that was free. And the kicker, my favorite part of the whole process, was that again, we’d been in the home for five years, so when they came out to do the appraisal, they looked at the improvements we’ve done, they looked at the market around us. We actually — I scheduled the appraisal the day after I knew a house down the street was closing.
Tim Ulbrich: Well played, well played.
Nate Hedrick: It helps to be an agent, right? And so we had this great other property supporting our value. And we gained like $30,000 in equity — actually, $35,000 in equity from when we purchased the house. So immediately after we refinanced, we went out and we got a home equity line of credit for the extra equity that we’d built in. And it was a great way for us to kind of group those together and set ourselves up for more success.
Tim Ulbrich: Such a good example of reasons to refinance. Not only the lower rate, but obviously you mentioned the PMI piece but then also with the increase equity, opening up a HELOC option if you’re trying to do other things, which I know you are, real estate investing, things like that. So I think too, this was a good reminder — and I had a chance to talk with that institution, just trying to learn more — it’s a good reminder of just to think creatively and look at all solutions. And if I understand this specific product correctly, it’s not a new product. But it makes sense in the current interest rate market that we’re in whereas historically, maybe it hasn’t made as much sense. And what I’ve found is that as I compared that option for us where we think we’re going to be in the home for a very, very long time, it wasn’t as competitive rate-wise.
Nate Hedrick: Right.
Tim Ulbrich: But I think that was what was unique about your situation is that perhaps there’s a move in the shorter term. And to find a solution that had maybe not the best rate but a close rate but didn’t have all the costs up front made sense for your situation. So I think, again, just a reminder that there’s not one solution that fits everyone out there.
Nate Hedrick: And for us too, it didn’t even reduce our monthly payment. I think I mentioned already, but we dropped from a 30-year, which we had paid five years on, down to a 15-year loan, so the idea being that if we are here for a little bit longer period of time, now we’ve got — we’re overall reducing the cost of the total cost of the loan by taking off that 10 years. So we didn’t actually reduce our payment by that much every single month, but the overall value of it was there.
Tim Ulbrich: Awesome. So Nate, this is great stuff. And as always, love having you on the show, picking your brain. Here, we’re talking about refinancing. But I know there’s some listeners that maybe aren’t in a refinance situation, might be looking to buy for the first time or they’re in a home and instead of looking at refinance, they want to actually move to another home. And then I think we’ve got that unique connection with you and the concierge service that we do with obviously you wearing the dual hat of a pharmacist as well as a real estate agent. So tell our listeners more about for those that are in that situation, either buying for the first time or looking to move, where they can go to learn more and what that service is all about.
Nate Hedrick: Yeah, absolutely. So through our partnership together, we’ve kind of launched the YFP concierge services, which is a great home buying experience you can take part in for absolutely free. The way it works is you work with me, we have a 30-minute planning call, kind of go through some of your priorities, talk about budget, talk about what you’re looking for in a home, location, all that great stuff, to figure out what’s going to be a good fit for you. And then I actually set you up with a local real estate agent. One of the things that I do is interview a bunch of local agents in the area that you’re looking, make sure I’ve got somebody that’s going to line up with your priorities and what you have in mind. And then I get you guys connected and I stay a part of that process the whole time. So we’ve had a number of clients actually go through the concierge services to find a home. We’ve had some in Baltimore, I’m working with one in Washington right now. We’re kind of all over the place, which is really fun. And it’s been a great way to if you don’t know the area very well or if you don’t know any agent in the area or you just want that peace of mind knowing that you’re going to get somebody really good that’s been vetted by another real estate agent, it’s a great opportunity to kind of work with us to make sure that you’re getting the best experience possible.
Tim Ulbrich: Awesome. So to our community members, you can go to YourFinancialPharmacist.com, and then we have a page you’ll see there, you can click on at the top. We have a header “Buy or Refi a Home.” And from there, we have an option to find an agent, and you’ll see more information about being able to connect and work with Nate. So Nate, thank you as always, and looking forward to having you on at APhA this year. So for our community members that will be at APhA, Nate will be joining us out there at the booth. So we hope you’ll stop by and say hello. And as always, appreciate your contribution to the show.
Nate Hedrick: Happy to be here, as always.
Tim Ulbrich: Awesome. And as a reminder to our listeners, if you like what you heard on this week’s episode of the Your Financial Pharmacist podcast, please leave us a rating and review in Apple podcasts or wherever you listen to your podcasts each and every week. Have a great rest of your week.
Current Student Loan Refinance Offers
[wptb id="15454" not found ]Recent Posts
[pt_view id=”f651872qnv”]
